FullMetal Alchemist Question

Ed x Winry and Roy x Riza fans, come on in!

Moderators: Beck, Caliborn

zapenstap
Fanfic demi-god(dess)|Fanfic demi-god|Fanfic demi-goddess
Posts: 253
Joined: Sat Apr 13, 2002 6:00 pm

Post by zapenstap »

He grows up!!!!! I've been waiting for Ed to do that but since he never did I just kinda assumed in my weird little mind that the mishap with his mother and brother messed with his body and he didn't grow. Was the movie pretty good?
Oh yes! Ed certainly grows up by the end of the show. Actually, I think FMA is one of the best coming-of-age animes that I've ever seen. It's not just that Ed starts to look older and act more responsible, but you can actually /feel/ how he changes over the course of a couple of episodes. The final kick that propels Ed into adulthood occurs in the last 3 episodes or so, though it starts sooner than that and is documented throughout the entire show. It's absolutely perfect because Ed /thinks/ he's an adult when he becomes a State Alchemist but his notion of what it really means to be an adult and understand the world as an adult understands it changes dramatically toward the end of the show. The crux of the change is echoed a lot in other coming-of-age stories, but because it is so central to the entire plot and premise of FMA, I found it to be particularly moving for Ed.

I hope that doesn't spoil anything. I'm trying to make my point without being too transparent.

It's great, though! I hope you like it ^^
Don't mess with me. I'm armed and dangerous.

zapenstap
Fanfic demi-god(dess)|Fanfic demi-god|Fanfic demi-goddess
Posts: 253
Joined: Sat Apr 13, 2002 6:00 pm

Post by zapenstap »

HEY! No one answered the Ed x Winry ROmance thing-ee.
Like a lot of shounen, the romance plot is weak and left open-ended in the show. I'm not sure what happens in the movie because I haven't seen it yet, but I wouldn't cross your fingers.

However, the romance is somewhat more developed in the manga, or at least what has come out so far since it is still going. Although we don't really know yet if Ed has any feelings for Winry beyond friendship, Winry has a little soliloquy where she thinks on how Ed has changed and how her feelings toward him have changed since they were kids. Nothing beyond that though.

So don't hold your breath!

However, I'm not disappointed. I'm not particularly for or against the EdxWinry pairing as it wasn't the most interesting thing about the show for me or why I wanted to watch it. I'm much more interested in Ed's fraternal relationship with Al and would actually be a little sad if a girl came between them and messed up that bond! I would like everybody to be happy, but I don't know if Winry wants to hang out her window waiting forever and I don't think Ed is going to care much about spending his energy on girls until he has buried the ghosts of his past, mended his family, and settled some of his restless, push-people-away-for-their-protection, go-it-alone spirit. And I doubt the movie will take things quite that far. Contented people aren't as interesting to watch after all! So you'll probably be left with fluffy fanfiction for all your romantic needs. lol.

Isn't that the way it always is? ^_~
Don't mess with me. I'm armed and dangerous.

Caliborn
Naughty Songstress of BI
Posts: 2441
Joined: Sat Mar 22, 2003 9:53 pm
Location: Chasing sanity
Contact:

Post by Caliborn »

Always. :) All the best anime couples usually have to be explored in fanfiction for the most part... HxR, for example. :wink:

Any idea when the movie is gonna be availible in the US?
One day, we will all look back on this moment, laugh nervously and change the subject.
-Annonymous

I want to live forever or die in the attempt.
-Annonymous

~Temptress Goddess of Vengeance
~CEO of the Hentai Charity League

"Puppy McPup?"
"For G**sakes, no!"


Andrea is the most beautiful, amazing sister on earth... when she's not being a meanie.

trekkiexb5
BI's Resident Sci Fi and Fantasy Expert
Posts: 615
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:30 am
Location: traveling the 4th dimension or visiting Caboose in Blood Gulch.
Contact:

Post by trekkiexb5 »

I heard directly after they released this upcoming episodes (second season?) Whenever they do, I'll have it on reserve. Suncoast has money for life. sigh.
goddess of the sea
Tolkien female
Lover of 20 ft. long scarves, jelly babies, and police call boxes. AND DAVID TENNANT!!! <swoons>
:salute:

"I don't want to die. I want to live. Or, a cowboy."
-Caboose

:-P

sinistergothvenus
Bishounen Strip Club Special Guest|Mobile Armor Pilot in Training
Posts: 436
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 6:16 pm
Location: The deepest pit of Hell
Contact:

Post by sinistergothvenus »

I completely agree with you, zapenstrap. But i still wish that they would put just a little more effort into the romance part of their animes. Of course, I guess that would just be my girly side coming out. 8) I don't do that very often. :D

later!!!
What do I see? I see time as it affects all things. Human flesh whithers and dies before my eyes. Flowers bloom, only to fade. Trees drop green leaves, never to retain them. In my sight, it is always winter, always night.

- Raistlin (DragonLance Series :study: )


http://www.myspace.com/ashmeadow Find me on MySpace! http://www.myspace.com/animefangirl3476
</a>

zapenstap
Fanfic demi-god(dess)|Fanfic demi-god|Fanfic demi-goddess
Posts: 253
Joined: Sat Apr 13, 2002 6:00 pm

Post by zapenstap »

For Ed and Winry in the movie........


****spoiler****

I have heard (rumor alert) that there is a close-quarter and emotional "hugging" scene that might put the romance on par with the end of Endless Waltz, but I can't be too specific about it. My guess would be that there are continued hints but nothing definite. My hunch is that it will be clear that Winry has feelings for Ed and yes, he might return them, but circumstances (whatever they are by the end of the movie)... or the current emotional development of the characters...or just the trajectory of plot... won't sum up to anything "conclusive" for the pairing. You will probably still be able to argue between "they are friends" and "they are friends with something more growing."

Just my guess!
Don't mess with me. I'm armed and dangerous.

trekkiexb5
BI's Resident Sci Fi and Fantasy Expert
Posts: 615
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:30 am
Location: traveling the 4th dimension or visiting Caboose in Blood Gulch.
Contact:

Post by trekkiexb5 »

bastards!! I guess that's why sites likethis exist.
goddess of the sea
Tolkien female
Lover of 20 ft. long scarves, jelly babies, and police call boxes. AND DAVID TENNANT!!! <swoons>
:salute:

"I don't want to die. I want to live. Or, a cowboy."
-Caboose

:-P

sinistergothvenus
Bishounen Strip Club Special Guest|Mobile Armor Pilot in Training
Posts: 436
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 6:16 pm
Location: The deepest pit of Hell
Contact:

Post by sinistergothvenus »

trekkiexb5 wrote:bastards!! I guess that's why sites likethis exist.
U know it!!!!!! :o We just have to make it up ourselves!
Oh well, that works for me. I think the authors of fanfiction have a very vivid imagination for romance. :oops: :)

later!!! :evil:
What do I see? I see time as it affects all things. Human flesh whithers and dies before my eyes. Flowers bloom, only to fade. Trees drop green leaves, never to retain them. In my sight, it is always winter, always night.

- Raistlin (DragonLance Series :study: )


http://www.myspace.com/ashmeadow Find me on MySpace! http://www.myspace.com/animefangirl3476
</a>

Caliborn
Naughty Songstress of BI
Posts: 2441
Joined: Sat Mar 22, 2003 9:53 pm
Location: Chasing sanity
Contact:

Post by Caliborn »

I bet Inuyasha would've never had as much romance as it did if it hadn't been so central to the plot. @.@ And even then, there was... -one- kissing scene between the main couple out of a hundred and a half episodes and four movies? @.@
One day, we will all look back on this moment, laugh nervously and change the subject.
-Annonymous

I want to live forever or die in the attempt.
-Annonymous

~Temptress Goddess of Vengeance
~CEO of the Hentai Charity League

"Puppy McPup?"
"For G**sakes, no!"


Andrea is the most beautiful, amazing sister on earth... when she's not being a meanie.

sinistergothvenus
Bishounen Strip Club Special Guest|Mobile Armor Pilot in Training
Posts: 436
Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 6:16 pm
Location: The deepest pit of Hell
Contact:

Post by sinistergothvenus »

I'm with u on that. I think they should have gotten rid of kikyo and let inuyasha and kagome have a more romantic relationship than they do now. I don't even know why they keep kikyo around. she just wanders the land and does something small to help or just looks in on events. its kinda annoying.
What do I see? I see time as it affects all things. Human flesh whithers and dies before my eyes. Flowers bloom, only to fade. Trees drop green leaves, never to retain them. In my sight, it is always winter, always night.

- Raistlin (DragonLance Series :study: )


http://www.myspace.com/ashmeadow Find me on MySpace! http://www.myspace.com/animefangirl3476
</a>

Post Reply

Return to “Full Metal Alchemist”