Page 2 of 2
Posted: Mon May 05, 2003 3:25 am
by RyanEX2000
Well....if you intend to horrify the rest of us GW fans by advancing this.I have hust one thing to say.......
Could you at least pair Heero up with Noin.If you're gonna do such an out and away pairing,I hope you're not letting 01 end up on his lonesome......again.
By the by,this idea would work with just about any pilot,but I guess that since Trowa is the current trend,you'd want to start with him.Maybe in a coupla months when he's been tossed aside for Quatre or Wufei we'll see a similar idea pop up.........provided of course you even finish this one(snickers).
Posted: Mon May 05, 2003 12:58 pm
by blackrose
LOL!!!
*sides with Ryan*
But geh, 1x9?
Oh well....
Love,
Rose <--who feels like maybe she should be more tactful, but still sides with Ryan anyway....
* Gasp *
Posted: Mon May 05, 2003 3:52 pm
by Nausica?
Let me make this clear: Trowa Barton is not and never will be a trend!
Oh well, to each his own - and mine's Trowa!
I don't know about the other ladies, but I'd not dump Heero like so much rubbish. I don't know who he'd end up with, but I'd rather not let him be alone either. It's not for me to say, though. It's a group decision. What do you think Dark? Wicked?
- Naus
Posted: Mon May 05, 2003 5:13 pm
by RyanEX2000
Psssshhhhh
!
I'm sure that's what all those 2xR fic writers said not too long ago.And what do you know!!!!While those fics've pretty much dried up,3xR has suddenly picked up.
But seriously,that is something of note,don't you agree.Anywho,PLEASE 1x9,1x9.If there's one Alt pairing I truly like it's 1x9.If you're gonna have Rel meet Trowa first.How bout having Heero hide out at Noin's base.It'd be fun to see Noin agonise over two reticent soldiers who've caught her heart and..........(whap)
"Ow,hey what......"
Rose:"don't give them any ideas"
Ryan"why not?"
Rose"You want to see Rel get with Trowa."
Ryan"Not really,but Heero deserves a more mature woman anyway."
Rose"What??"
Wicked"I knew you'd see my side."
Ryan"Not really.I'd just like to see if Mr 'I'm a human top' would be able to endure Rel's stalker habits.Let's if he's as eager to go after another guys' girl after this."
Being attacked am I/are we?
Posted: Mon May 05, 2003 7:12 pm
by Dark Deity
To Ryan: *Glare* :evil: Be glad i do not moderate this forum. But, as Naus said, to each there own. I definately do not agree about the Heero/Noin idea. Not at all. Unless Wicked or Naus would like to also change Zechs and Noins positions/pasts' then i suggest it not be done. At least not in this fic. Ryan, your faith in us astounds me. I wouldn't have Heero alone, and we will decide what to do with him. There are still many Duo/Lena fics about, you obvously do not look, seeing as AP's are not your thing, and seeing as this is an AP forum, i'd prefer you'd keep to yourself a bit more. Sorry if i am taking slight offense when i shouldn't, but i do not like it when some one suggests certain things ("if you intend to horrify the rest of us GW fans " and "provided of course you even finish this one(snickers).") If you do not want to read the fic, nor want it around, simply do not read it, and keep comments about it to yourself. Critisizing something that does not yet exist is something i find very annoying. I will stop here on that subject, because i don't want to babble much more, leading to a rant.... As for Trowa/Lena being a trend... Hardly. And would you even know? If you were jsut joking about anything you have said in your past two posts here, i'll just ask you to make it more obvious.
Wicked/Naus: Well, i know i will need to find my descriptions of the episodes. Now we must decide how and who will start. May i suggest talking through IMs and/or email from here on about the fic, and writing it of course. We could just leave this to those who have an (wanted or unwanted) opinion on the idea, and/or wish to add ideas, maybe write where we get stuck. Things like that. My email is soulessjest@aol.com and that goes for my Screen name as well. Hope to here from you guyes soon.
Dark Deity
-Ryry-
PS, if i have, i did not mean to bring down the mood of this forum, but i needed my opinion to be out there as well. :-?
Posted: Mon May 05, 2003 8:19 pm
by Symee-Sama
I'd read this fic no problem, but I have to agree with Ryan when he said that 2xR has died down a bit, and 3xR has become more popular. That's not saying that it won't continue to be popular though. I have another comment to make to Ryan on who you'd pair Heero with.
I honestly cannot picture 1xR. Heero and Noin? It's sorta gross in my opinion. She's four years older than him, and that makes a HUGE difference. There is no way that they'd get together. Plus, she's stuck on Zechs. Anyway, I too, don't want Heero to be left alone, but I'd rather that you don't pair him up with Noin or Dorothy. You could create a character for him to be with...
Symee
Posted: Mon May 05, 2003 9:34 pm
by blackrose
My personal opinion is that re-telling the series is not my cup of tea. If GW is so fundamentally flawed that it needs to be re-written, then why are we even fans of it. I find it disrespectful, in a way, to the creators when people go through and just re-write entire chunks of the show in order to suit their pairing preferences, but as someone said, to each his/her own.
I'm shutting down this topic because it has gotten unfriendly. I don't think that what Ryan said was all that bad, personally, though it could have been a bit more tactful, and the "snickers" may have been a bit out of line. This IS the Alternatives forum, you guys are free to like 2xR/3xR whatever. But let's be respectful to each other, and let's remember that no ONE viewpoint on this is either right or wrong.
~Rose
*hugs* Oh wait, I said I didn't think I'd respond didn't I? *sigh* Well I lied. 